Teenagers from schools across the USA share their insights on the importance of writing skills in the era of artificial intelligence, underscoring the enduring value of human creativity and expression in effective communication.
Students Discuss Writing in the Age of A.I.
In the January 25, 2024, edition of The Learning Network, teenagers shared their perspectives on the value of learning to write amidst the rise of artificial intelligence (AI) programs like ChatGPT. The conversation was prompted by an essay from Opinion contributor Frank Bruni, who argued that effective communication remains crucial despite technological advancements.
Many students from schools such as Glenbard North High School (Carol Stream, IL), Hinsdale Central High School (Hinsdale, IL), and New Rochelle High School (New Rochelle, NY) contributed to the discussion. They voiced concerns about the implications of AI on writing skills and the importance of personal expression.
Several students emphasized the practicality of learning to write well, noting that skills in communication, creativity, and problem-solving are irreplaceable by AI. They argued that writing helps articulate personal thoughts and perspectives, which AI cannot replicate authentically.
Some students highlighted the satisfaction derived from writing, underscoring the importance of self-expression and creativity. Others raised ethical concerns, warning against the risk of plagiarism when using AI-generated content and stressing the need for original writing.
Several participants acknowledged using AI as a resource rather than a replacement. They suggested AI could assist in generating ideas or making grammar corrections but maintained that human input is crucial for nuanced and meaningful writing.
The conversation also touched on the future role of AI in writing, with some students predicting that AI might eventually handle basic writing tasks. However, they remained skeptical that AI could ever fully capture the creativity and emotional depth of human writers.
In summary, the students broadly agreed that while AI offers various tools to assist with writing, the fundamental skills of good writing, rooted in human creativity and critical thought, remain indispensable.
